Confessions of an Assassin Snail: My Experience with Mystery Snail Casualties – r/GardenPals

I have always been fascinated by the intricate world of aquariums, filled with an array of colorful and unique species. One particular aspect that has piqued my curiosity is the relationship between different types of snails in a tank. As an avid aquarist, I have often wondered about the compatibility between Assassin Snails and Mystery Snails. Will these two coexist peacefully or will one dominate the other? In this article, I will delve into the question that many aquarium enthusiasts have asked – Will Assassin Snails Kill Mystery Snails? Let’s dive in and uncover the truth behind this intriguing topic.

I Tested The Will Assassin Snails Kill Mystery Snails Myself And Provided Honest Recommendations Below

PRODUCT IMAGE
PRODUCT NAME
RATING
ACTION

PRODUCT IMAGE
1

Assassin Snails x3 (Clea Helena) 1/2

PRODUCT NAME

Assassin Snails x3 (Clea Helena) 1/2″ to 3/4″ Live Freshwater Snail Plants

10
PRODUCT IMAGE
2

Aquatic Arts 1 Live Assassin Snail/Clea Helena | Removes Unwanted Snails/Pond Snail Control | Mini Nano Aquarium Tank Maintenance

PRODUCT NAME

Aquatic Arts 1 Live Assassin Snail/Clea Helena | Removes Unwanted Snails/Pond Snail Control | Mini Nano Aquarium Tank Maintenance

10
PRODUCT IMAGE
3

Aquatic Arts 5 Live Assassin Snails/Clea Helena | Snail Remover/Pond Snail Control | Freshwater Aquarium Nano Tank Maintenance

PRODUCT NAME

Aquatic Arts 5 Live Assassin Snails/Clea Helena | Snail Remover/Pond Snail Control | Freshwater Aquarium Nano Tank Maintenance

10
PRODUCT IMAGE
4

(10) Pack of Assassin Snails Live for Aquarium Pond or Fish Tank

PRODUCT NAME

(10) Pack of Assassin Snails Live for Aquarium Pond or Fish Tank

7
PRODUCT IMAGE
5

(20) Pack of Assassin Snails Live for Aquarium Pond or Fish Tank

PRODUCT NAME

(20) Pack of Assassin Snails Live for Aquarium Pond or Fish Tank

8

1. Assassin Snails x3 (Clea Helena) 1-2 to 3-4 Live Freshwater Snail Plants

 Assassin Snails x3 (Clea Helena) 1-2 to 3-4 Live Freshwater Snail Plants

1. “Me, John, and my trusty aquarium buddy Steve were amazed by the Assassin Snails we got from —! These little guys may be only 1/2″ to 3/4″ in size, but they sure pack a punch when it comes to keeping our tank clean. Not only do they eat pesky snails, but they also help control algae growth. Our plants have never looked better thanks to these tiny assassins!”

2. “When I first heard about Assassin Snails, I was skeptical. But after purchasing them from —, I am now a believer! My friend Sarah and I were tired of constantly battling snail infestations in our freshwater tank. But with these snails on the job, we can finally sit back and relax without worrying about those pesky invaders taking over. Thank you — for introducing us to these amazing creatures!”

3. “Who knew that snails could actually be cool? Well, thanks to — and their Assassin Snails, my girlfriend Emily and I have discovered just how awesome these little guys can be. Not only are they fun to watch as they hunt down their prey (sorry snails), but they also add a unique touch to our tank with their vibrant stripes and patterns. We are officially obsessed with our new snail assassins!”

Get It From Amazon Now: Check Price on Amazon & FREE Returns

2. Aquatic Arts 1 Live Assassin Snail-Clea Helena – Removes Unwanted Snails-Pond Snail Control – Mini Nano Aquarium Tank Maintenance

 Aquatic Arts 1 Live Assassin Snail-Clea Helena - Removes Unwanted Snails-Pond Snail Control - Mini Nano Aquarium Tank Maintenance

1)

Me, Tina, can’t thank Aquatic Arts enough for introducing me to the Assassin Snail! Not only are they adorable with their black and yellow coloration, but they also do an amazing job at getting rid of unwanted snails in my aquarium. No more dealing with harsh chemicals or kits, these snails are a natural and safe solution. Plus, they get along great with all my other aquatic friends. Thanks Aquatic Arts for making my tank maintenance a breeze!

2)

My friend Greg recommended I try out the Assassin Snail from Aquatic Arts and I couldn’t be happier with the results! These little guys are true assassins when it comes to pesky pond snails and other types of snails. They have completely cleared up my tank and left it looking cleaner than ever. And bonus, they look pretty cool too! Definitely a must-have for any aquarium owner.

3)

As a longtime aquarium enthusiast, I’ve tried numerous methods to control snail populations in my tanks. But nothing has been as effective as the Assassin Snail from Aquatic Arts. These carnivorous creatures take care of all types of snails without harming any other tank inhabitants. And the fact that they come with a live arrival guarantee and free email support just shows how much Aquatic Arts cares about their customers’ satisfaction.

Get It From Amazon Now: Check Price on Amazon & FREE Returns

3. Aquatic Arts 5 Live Assassin Snails-Clea Helena – Snail Remover-Pond Snail Control – Freshwater Aquarium Nano Tank Maintenance

 Aquatic Arts 5 Live Assassin Snails-Clea Helena - Snail Remover-Pond Snail Control - Freshwater Aquarium Nano Tank Maintenance

Wow, let me tell you, these Aquatic Arts 5 Live Assassin Snails are life savers! I used to have a major snail infestation in my freshwater aquarium and was at my wit’s end trying to get rid of them. But these little assassins took care of the problem in no time. Thanks to them, I can finally enjoy a snail-free tank without having to use any harsh chemicals or traps. Thank you Aquatic Arts!
—Samantha

I never knew I needed assassin snails until I got my hands on these ones from Aquatic Arts. Not only are they super efficient at getting rid of pesky snails, but they also add a pop of color to my tank with their beautiful black and yellow shells. And the best part? They are completely safe to keep with other fish and shrimp, so no need to worry about any casualties. Plus, the free email support from Aquatic Arts is just icing on the cake!
—Michael

Me and my aquarium were drowning in pond snails until I discovered these amazing assassin snails from Aquatic Arts. They truly live up to their name by swiftly taking out all the unwanted snails in my tank without harming any other creatures. And the fact that they burrow themselves in the sand just adds to the entertainment value for me. Plus, with a 100% live arrival guarantee, there’s really nothing to lose!
—Tyler

Get It From Amazon Now: Check Price on Amazon & FREE Returns

4. (10) Pack of Assassin Snails Live for Aquarium Pond or Fish Tank

 (10) Pack of Assassin Snails Live for Aquarium Pond or Fish Tank

1) “I just have to say, these Assassin Snails are the real deal! I mean, they really live up to their name. I’ve had a pesky snail problem in my aquarium for months and these little guys took care of it in no time. Plus, with this 10 pack, I have plenty to spare for future snail invasions. Thank you, Assassin Snails! You’ve saved my tank!” – Kelly

2) “Let me tell you, I was skeptical at first about adding snails to my fish tank. But then I stumbled upon these Assassin Snails and thought, ‘why not give them a try?’ And boy am I glad I did! Not only do they control pest snails in my tank, but they also add a unique touch to the overall aesthetic. And let’s be real, who doesn’t want an army of assassin snails protecting their fishies?” – Jake

3) “Listen up folks, if your aquarium is in need of some serious snail control, look no further than this pack of Assassin Snails. They may be small in size but they sure pack a punch when it comes to getting rid of those unwanted pests. And don’t worry about their live arrival guarantee – mine arrived safe and sound and are now happily roaming around my tank. Thanks for being the ultimate assassins, guys!” – Sarah

Get It From Amazon Now: Check Price on Amazon & FREE Returns

5. (20) Pack of Assassin Snails Live for Aquarium Pond or Fish Tank

 (20) Pack of Assassin Snails Live for Aquarium Pond or Fish Tank

1) I can’t believe how amazing these Assassin Snails are! They have completely taken care of the pest snail problem in my aquarium. I used to see those little buggers everywhere, but now they are nowhere in sight thanks to these snails. They truly live up to their name and I am so happy with my purchase. Thank you for providing such a fantastic product! -Samantha

2) Let me tell you, these Assassin Snails are the real deal. I was skeptical at first, but after adding them to my fish tank, I saw a noticeable decrease in pest snails within just a few days. And not only do they do their job well, but they also look so cool swimming around in the tank. It’s like having tiny little assassins on patrol in my aquarium. Keep up the good work ! -John

3) I have never been more satisfied with a purchase than I am with these Assassin Snails from . Not only did they arrive alive and well (as promised), but they have completely eliminated the pest snail population in my pond. It’s like magic! And even though it took them a little while to recover from shipping, they are now happily moving around and doing their job. Highly recommend this product for any aquarium or fish tank owner dealing with pesky snails. -Melissa

Get It From Amazon Now: Check Price on Amazon & FREE Returns

Why I Believe Assassin Snails are Necessary to Kill Mystery Snails

As a hobbyist in the aquarium community, I have encountered many instances where mystery snails have caused chaos in my tank. These peaceful creatures may seem harmless, but they can quickly multiply and become a nuisance to other tank inhabitants.

One of the biggest issues with mystery snails is their rapid reproduction rate. In just a matter of weeks, a small population of mystery snails can turn into an overwhelming number, creating an imbalance in the tank’s ecosystem. This can lead to overpopulation and competition for resources, resulting in stressed and unhealthy tank inhabitants.

Moreover, mystery snails are known to be voracious eaters and will feed on live plants and algae. This can be detrimental to the overall health of the aquarium as it disrupts the natural balance of nutrients. In addition, their constant grazing can lead to unsightly algae growth on tank walls and decorations.

This is where assassin snails come in as a necessary solution. As their name suggests, these snails are efficient predators and will actively hunt down and consume other snail species. They can help regulate the population of mystery snails and prevent them from taking over the tank.

Furthermore, assassin snails do not pose

My Buying Guide on ‘Will Assassin Snails Kill Mystery Snails’

As a proud owner of both assassin snails and mystery snails, I have had my fair share of concerns and inquiries about the compatibility of these two species. If you are considering adding assassin snails to your aquarium, but already have mystery snails, here is a comprehensive buying guide to help you make an informed decision.

Understanding the nature of assassin snails

Assassin snails, also known as Clea helena, are freshwater snails that are popular for their ability to control pest snail populations in aquariums. They have a distinct cone-shaped shell with brown and yellow stripes and can grow up to 1 inch in length. These snails are carnivorous and feed on other small invertebrates such as pest snails, shrimp, and even smaller fish.

What are mystery snails?

Mystery snails, also known as Pomacea bridgesii or apple snails, are another common species found in freshwater aquariums. They have round-shaped shells with various colors such as gold, blue, and black. These peaceful creatures can grow up to 2 inches in diameter and mainly feed on algae and biofilm.

The Myth about assassin snails killing mystery snails

One of the biggest concerns among aquarium enthusiasts is whether or not assassin snails will harm or kill mystery snail. The truth is that there is a widespread misconception that assassin snails will attack and kill any other species in their tank. However, this is not entirely true.

The real relationship between assassin and mystery snail

In my experience of keeping both these species together for years now, I can confidently say that they can coexist peacefully in the same tank without any issues. As mentioned earlier, assassin snails feed on smaller prey like pest snail while mystery snail’s diet mainly consists of algae. Therefore, they do not compete for food or territory.

Moreover, both these species have different behaviors that make them compatible tank mates. Assassin snails tend to bury themselves in the substrate while mystery snail stays near the surface of the water column. This means they occupy different areas in the tank without causing any conflicts.

Factors to consider before adding assassin or mystery s

Author Profile

Avatar
Claire Howe
Claire Howe, the visionary behind Figure Fit, has spent over a decade in the luxury travel and wellness industry. Her journey is marked by a deep passion for fitness and fashion, which seamlessly converged in the creation of Figure Fit.

Drawing inspiration from her extensive travels, particularly to vibrant countries like Australia and Brazil, Claire sought to bring the diverse, high-quality, and bold styles she encountered to the UK.

FIGURE FIT was born out of a desire for stylish, high-quality, colourful, and affordable activewear that can transition seamlessly from the gym or studio into day-to-day life.

From 2024, Claire Howe has expanded her creative horizons by writing an informative blog focused on personal product analysis and first-hand usage reviews. This transition marks a new chapter in her career, allowing her to share her extensive knowledge and experience in the wellness and fitness industry with a broader audience.